top of page

Controlling the Narrative

Updated: Sep 23

Two men portrayed as puppets, controlled by large hands with strings. Left: a man at a desk; right: a man speaking with a mic, outdoors.
Who stands to benefit most from this? (Jimmy Kimmel on the Left and Charle Kirk on the Right.)

Every generation has its battles. Some are fought with swords, others are fought with cameras, and still others are fought with voices. Today, the battle is over who gets to tell the stories—and who gets silenced.


Free speech is under unprecedented strain. Federal support for the arts has been slashed; grants are tied to ideology rather than artistic merit. Major studios are being swallowed by billionaire-backed conglomerates. AI threatens not just actors, but cinematographers, editors, teamsters—the entire human heartbeat of film. And when comedians, talk show hosts, or activists speak out, political and corporate power may not just push back—they cancel them.


When Voices Are Silenced


Charlie Kirk’s Assassination & the Aftermath


On September 10, 2025, conservative activist Charlie Kirk was assassinated while speaking at Utah Valley University. His ideology was divisive, discriminatory, and to many, deeply damaging. But murder is not justice. His killing shocked the nation—and what followed raised deeper questions. Workers across industries were disciplined or fired for commentary about Kirk’s death. Comedians and journalists were suspended for pushing against the official narrative. Even in his death, voices were silenced for speaking of him at all.


Split image of theater signs; left reads "Jimmy Kimmel Live!" with "SUSPENDED," right reads "The Late Show with Stephen Colbert" with "CANCELED."
Split screen of Jimmy Kimmel's studio from the outdoors in LA. On the right-hand side is Stephen Colbert's studio.

Jimmy Kimmel


Shortly after, Jimmy Kimmel Live! was suspended indefinitely. Kimmel had remarked that “many in MAGA land are working very hard to characterize this kid who murdered Charlie Kirk as anything other than one of them and doing everything they can to score political points from it.” Affiliates pulled the show; ABC caved to pressure. A late-night platform—gone.


Stephen Colbert


Stephen Colbert’s Late Show is scheduled to end in 2026. CBS cited finances, but many believe the real reason is clear: Colbert has long been a critic of those in power, and networks no longer tolerate dissent. When Kimmel was suspended, Colbert called it “blatant censorship.” His words now serve as a warning: the moment you challenge the narrative, your platform is at risk.


A large man controls marionette filmmakers in a film studio setting, surrounded by robots with cameras. The word "STUDIOS" is visible.
Larry Ellison Pulls the Strings at Skydance and Paramount. He's now after Warner Bros.

Studio Consolidation: Billionaire Control


At the same time, Hollywood’s landscape is shrinking. Skydance Media, funded by Oracle heir David Ellison, merged with Paramount Global in an $8 billion deal—and is already circling Warner Bros. Discovery. Legendary Entertainment, home of Dune and Godzilla, is now owned by Apollo Global Management. Amazon owns MGM.


Every merger hands more cultural power to billionaires. Fewer owners means fewer risks. Fewer risks means fewer diverse voices. Consolidation narrows not just what gets made, but what’s even allowed to be imagined.


And on the horizon? Amazon’s AI division, and others like it, pouring billions into automating film. Not just actors, but entire crews—lighting, sound, editing, craft services. If the human component of film is stripped away, what’s left isn’t art—it’s content.



Silhouetted figures against a US map labeled "Gulf of America." One holds a document marked "TARIFFS," the other holds a pencil, labeled "GOOGLE."
Trump controlling the narrative of the USA by rewriting maps and more.


Who Benefits? (Controlling the Narrative)


Look at the pattern:

  • Comedians silenced.

  • Activists assassinated, then canonized.

  • Workers fired for speech.

  • Billionaires merging studios.

  • AI poised to erase human craft.

  • Federal funding for the arts slashed.


Every move shrinks freedom, concentrates power, narrows the narrative.

So the question must be asked: Who benefits most from all this? The answer: The one who controls the narrative.


Why Independent Voices Must Rise


Independent creators are the antidote. They are not owned by oligarchs. They are not beholden to billion-dollar mergers. They are free to take risks, to provoke, to tell stories that matter. They keep alive the plurality of voices that democracy depends on.

But they cannot survive without your support. When you share their work, fund their projects, or amplify their voices, you are defending not just art—you are defending free speech itself.


The stars of Ordinary Heroes: The Crosses We Bear. From left to right: Tommy Bayiokos, JR Carter, Anthony Robert Grasso and Chaise Cortes De Vargas at the bottom center.
The stars of Ordinary Heroes: The Crosses We Bear. From left to right: Tommy Bayiokos, JR Carter, Anthony Robert Grasso and Chaise Cortes De Vargas in the bottom center.


ThematicShift: Our Vision


This is why ThematicShift exists. We were born at the picket lines of rebellion and are not a studio owned by billionaires. We are a collective. Our vision is bold: build a co-op, where ownership rests not with investors chasing profit, but with members who are vested in the kind of stories we want to see.


Together, we vote. Together, we fund. Together our voices rise.


The future of storytelling belongs to us—not to regimes, not to oligarchs, not to algorithms.


Conclusion


The death of free speech rarely comes with a bang. It comes in silence—one canceled show, one muted voice, one story never told. From Kirk to Kimmel to Colbert, from funding cuts to billion-dollar mergers, we see the pattern.


Protecting free speech means even protecting dissent. Supporting independents means refusing to let billionaires control the narrative.


That is the mission of ThematicShift: to rise as a chorus of independent voices, owned not by the few, but by the many.


Together, we rise. ✨✊

 
 
 

1 Comment

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

Magnificent article - well written, eye opening, and inspiring! Much success!

Like
bottom of page